Call number browse: Poppy issues

Issues reported related to Call number browse during Poppy dry runs

Report #1: Blocker

Additional examples of Other scheme call numbers

  • F54N H215 - Works as expected with both browsing options if copy number is included (“F54N H215”)

  • H +7N15t - Works as expected with both browsing options if exact shelving order is used (“H +7N15t no.11 11 1” likely challenging with the “+”)

  • P121 C3 1977

    • Not found if browsed directly in Other scheme - sometimes shows up in results with specific queries, such as “p”. However, if browsing “P121” it does not show in results, and “P121” is not sorted with the call numbers that do start with “P121”

    • Found in “Call numbers (all)” option if browsing with the copy number “P121 C3 1977 1” (though not found in “Other scheme” with the same query)

Call number type

Poppy Browse option

Browse criteria

Issue reported

Orchid bugfest - “Call numbers” option

Poppy bugfest - Poppy bugfest specific browse option

Notes

Call number type

Poppy Browse option

Browse criteria

Issue reported

Orchid bugfest - “Call numbers” option

Poppy bugfest - Poppy bugfest specific browse option

Notes

1

Other scheme

Call numbers (all)

F54P L54le

  • Call number does not appear in results set

  • Call number specified on Holdings

  • DOES return if the copy number “1” is added to the call number (F54P L54le 1)

Works as expected

Does not return in results set?

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in4115829

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in4115829

2

Other scheme

Other scheme

F54P L54le

  • Call number does not appear in results set

  • Does not return, even if copy number added

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in4115829

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in4115829

3

Other scheme

Call numbers (all)

47YF Se42u

  • Call number does not appear in results set

  • Call number specified on holdings

  • DOES return if the copy number “1” is added to the call number (47YF Se42u 1)

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in2069202

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in2069202

4

Other scheme

Other scheme

47YF Se42u

  • Call number does not appear in results set

  • Does not return, even if copy number added

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in2069202

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in2069202

 

Report #2: Not a blocker

Call number type

Poppy Browse option

Browse criteria

Issue reported

Orchid bugfest

Poppy bugfest

Notes

Call number type

Poppy Browse option

Browse criteria

Issue reported

Orchid bugfest

Poppy bugfest

Notes

1

Other scheme

Call numbers (all)

MSS 467

Call number does not appear in results set

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Tested with full string in callNumber field

  • Tested with “467” in suffix

  • Orchid bugfest instance: oin00011834001

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in00000087733

2

Other scheme

Other scheme

MSS 467

Call number does not appear in results set

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Tested with full string in callNumber field

  • Tested with “467” in suffix

  • Orchid bugfest instance: oin00011834001

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in00000087733

3

Other scheme

Call numbers (all)

2A8 C0061853 Music CD

Call number does not appear in results set

  • However, similar call number “2E7 C0071294 Music CD” does

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Tested with full string in callNumber field

  • Tested with “Music CD” in suffix field

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in7467486

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in7467486

4

Other scheme

Other scheme

2A8 C0061853 Music CD

Call number does not appear in results set

  • However, similar call number “2E7 C0071294 Music CD” does

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Tested with full string in callNumber field

  • Tested with “Music CD” in suffix field

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in7467486

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in7467486

5

Library of Congress classification

Call numbers (all)

TR647.A2353 A4 2012

Call number does not appear in results set

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Tested with full string in callNumber field

  • Tested with “2012” in suffix field

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in7453717

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in7453717

6

Library of Congress classification

Library of Congress classification

TR647.A2353 A4 2012

Call number does not appear in results set

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Tested with full string in callNumber field

  • Tested with “2012” in suffix field

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in7453717

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in7453717

7

SuDoc

Call numbers (all)

EP 1.1/11

Would be here message, but call number appears further down on the list.

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Orchid bugfest instance: ins00006949380

  • Poppy bugfest instance: ins00006949380

8

SuDoc

SuDoc

EP 1.1/11

Would be here message, but call number appears further down on the list.

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Orchid bugfest instance: ins00006949380

  • Poppy bugfest instance: ins00006949380

Report #3: MSEARCH-670

Call number type

Poppy Browse option

Browse criteria

Issue reported

Orchid bugfest

Poppy bugfest

Notes

Call number type

Poppy Browse option

Browse criteria

Issue reported

Orchid bugfest

Poppy bugfest

Notes

1

Dewey Decimal classification

Dewey Decimal classification

E B252h

Does not show up in results set

Works as expected

Does not return in results set

  • Orchid bugfest instancein11945390

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in11945390

2

Library of Congress classification

Library of Congress classification

NK4894.3.B37 T6713 1998

Does not show up in results set

Works as expected

Works as expected

  • Orchid bugfest instance: in00000132416

  • Poppy bugfest instance: in00000132416

  • Does show up in Call numbers (all)

Report #4: Waiting for examples, but reported that they are seeing differences in Orchid and Poppy