2022-06-16 CDL Sub-group Meeting Notes

Owned by Jana Freytag
Last updated: Jun 16, 2022
2 min read

Date


Zoom

https://zoom.us/j/337279319 (pw: folio-lsp)

Attendees

Sebastian Hammer 

Mark Canney 

Andy Horbal 

Andrea Loigman 

Erin Weller 

Sarah Seestone 

David Bottorff 

Peter Murray  

Shirley Moentnish 

Jana Freytag 


Discussion Items

TimeItemWhoDescriptionGoals/Info/notes
2minAdministrivia



Note taker:  

Jana Freytag 



Defining record requirements

This is the MVP requirements Document





Next steps


Meeting Notes

Report by Sebastian Hammer on the Presentation at the Internet Archive meeting in NY

  • Project 'Open Server':
    • Please fill in summary
  • Feedback:
  • Andrea: a good point but maybe not realistic

  • Andy Horbal in Chat: Another one of the reasons CDL was conceived, I think, is that publishers are hostile to the right of first sale for *physical* items, let alone digital. So it's hard for me to imagine a world in which they suddenly embrace this vision en masse.

  • Sarah: trying to avoid CDL since it is to labour intensive
  • Could be a best-practice project

  • Andy Horbal in Chat: My background is in film. Hollywood had, at best, mixed feelings about home video. They were ultimately won over by the massive amounts of profits they made during the 80s-00s, but remained deeply apprehensive about piracy. I'm worried that streaming actually represents a "best of both worlds" scenario for them. All of this goes for smaller distributors who cater the educational market as well: they just tend to frame the issue in terms of sustainability for filmmakers.

    ALL OF THAT SAID: I *love* that IA is working on this, and I think the creation of a framework that would allow some publishers to opt in to this can only be a positive development.

  • Should we make sure that cdl is compatible with other licensing frameworks?
  • Different types of patron access concerning cdl

  • Andy Horbal: +1 Sarah! This was a big problem with HaithiTrust ETAS: library patrons don't really care *that* much about how the item came to be available electronically, they just want it to do all the stuff they want it to do.


Where are we?

  • Having a CDL solution for FOLIO would benefit it's popularity and competitiveness on the market

  • ReShare integration - the first use case for ReShare is CDL for individual libraries, with ILL as a complement. ReShare wants Consortial CDL, but not to the exclusion of local CDL for the library’s patrons

  • We need a roadmap for CDL

  • This is the MVP requirements Document

  • Sarah will enrich the MVP document with requirements Stanford has
  • David Bottorff will reach out internally for further requirements
  • We still try to find someone by MM to join the group