Now that and have been implemented I believe the remianing use cases here are quite different. As a result I have created to continue refinening this funcitonality and will close this feature.

- OAI-PMH starting with Poppy release will support harvesting FOLIO instances as well. This work has been done in and .

If likely to be developed in the near future (at least it's scheduled), that does sound like it could be the the best long term solution. We just need to think of workaround in the meantime – I think semi-manual using Data Import could be fine, as the API already removes a lot of manual steps.

In that case, DI/mod-gobi work could be focused instead on https://folio-org.atlassian.net/browse/UXPROD-3699 instead, allowing to fully automate the "shelf-ready" service.

Hi Rather than messing with mod-gobi, the other option is that OAI-PMH should include Instances that are Source = FOLIO and not suppressed from discovery. That has bigger implications, but I thought that was planned also - just not sure when. See .

I know the background to this issue, and can confirm Anne-Marie's statement that the two are not duplicates (even if the titles could maybe be more explicit).

One big difference from the library POV is that the full MARC records referred to in https://folio-org.atlassian.net/browse/UXPROD-3699 are typically only transmitted to the library once the book order has been received and invoiced.

The library will however want the title to display in EDS as soon as they open the order on Gobi (and this generates the record in FOLIO). The library does not receive any MARC records at this point that they could manually import via DI.

As I understand, what mod-gobi receives from Gobi is actually a simple MARC record with order data. So to me it seems that a good solution would be if mod-gobi could take that MARC data and, after transmitting it to mod-orders and triggering the instance creation/linking order to existing instance, actually send it on to Data Import and load it to FOLIO it using some matching logic that ensures it only adds MARC to instances, never overwrites existing ones.